“For this to work … There has to be altruism in the universe”

And judging from so much of what goes on around us, their ain’t much altruism here on earth.

I could go on and on – foot binding, suicide bombers, The Darfur genocide, child pornography, the destruction of the environment, human trafficking, evil multinational corporations, famine, animal abuse, zombies, Fox News, and Tom Cruise’s ego – but it’s super depressing, so why bother recounting the endless list of our shortcomings as a species? You know what they are.

My dad used to do this SETI@home thing. Maybe he still does?

Regardless, the title of this post got me thinking. It came from this article I read entitled, “Scientist: Alien Life Could Already Be On Earth,” which wasn’t nearly as exciting nor fulfilling as one might’ve hoped. But I digress.

After suggesting the rather ho-hum premise that things such as organisms that live in hot springs (or my hot tub?) could have alien origin, he then digressed into a reflection about how our chances of having more exciting alien life show up are dwindling. You see, our former din of analog TV noise is disappearing as we switch to digital broadcasting, and we will soon become undetectable to other worlds. So not only is Comcast running an extortion scam on every last one of us, they’re ruining our chances of getting rescued off this rock and taken to a land where HBO is free.

Anyway, due to this looming lack of SOS, the scientists at SETI were excited by the possibility of using lasers to send super-bright flashes of light into space for a tiny fraction of a second and which could theoretically be seen by an advanced civilization up to 1,000 light years away. The issue, in the end, isn’t the signal so much as would any alien civilization would want anything to do with us in the first place?

Not the most attractive aliens on the block.

“For this to work … There has to be altruism in the universe.”

And not only altruism, but a complete and total lack of access to our media.

That or technological advancement combined with a stunning inability to judge character. Because, as we darn well know, unless they’ve come to blow us up, alien life would be best served to make a right turn at Jupiter and keep on going because we are one nasty and greedy plague.

Have you noticed that there are less and less true monster movies, and more and more ‘humans as monsters” movies. Where even the bad guys (aliens, vampires, vicious wild animals) in the end are the good guys when squared off with human beings? And don’t even get me started on all that “Saw” stuff.

I’m not saying it’s not all plausible, it’s just depressing.

Like District 9? I was despeartely hoping for the aliens to get out of South Africa and get away from us.

The Navi, on the other hand, are downright hot.

And Avatar made me wish I could move to Pandora, instead of walking outside to once again mingle with the kind of jerks that blow up and strip mine a beautiful and magical world in order to get at something they could sell for money.

I think what makes those plots so uncomfortable for me is that it’s not just feasible…it’s likely. It’s stuff we do every day to our own species and our own home. And it makes me wish the Navi existed and would be open to adopting me. Or even the District 9 ‘Prawns.’ They’re not much to look at, but I could adjust.

So what am I talking about?

I have no idea.

Maybe just that there probably is alien life out there, and they’ve gotten our Hitler broadcasts and Ku Klux Klan footage and listened to five minutes of The Howard Stern Show and realized we are not worth their time.

And perhaps our only hope is the fact that we’ve finally started to realize it and maybe can learn to collectively change our ways.

Or does that kind of stuff only happen in the movies?

Share This Post

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

2 Responses to ““For this to work … There has to be altruism in the universe””

  1. Jose

    Games Theory has a lot to say, about altruism. No strategy has ever won the “Tit for tat” at the iterated prissoner´s dylemma, which is quite like our real lives. Which means that collaboration pays off better than deception.

    You first have to be altruist, and then collaborate. If the other one deceipts, then you have to reprocicate (bad news for “the other cheek”), but then, forgive immediatelly and collaborate again.

    Bottom line: you better lose 99-100 than win 1-0! You get 98 extra whatevers! And still be generous enough to let the other win. Pure altruism, because you will NEVER “win”, with that strategy. You´ll only get the best possible outcome!!!

    The incredible news about this is that it is as indisputable as hard to understand, because it requires long term thought. Something most humans barely use.

    So the point is that once you reach a certain degree of intelligence, you should become MORE altruist. If ever because no-one will ALWAYS be the strongest one around; in competition, you are doomed to fail, sooner or later. But in an altruist environment, you´ll be better off, the worse things become. Interesting thought…

    The problem is that we don´t really know at what point of evolution that truth will be generally obvious. As you say in your last sentence, some humans seem to understand it already, but even though, I am not sure it would be a good idea to try and meet superior alien cultures, to check.

    As by today, every superior living creature have used the lessers to feed themselves, get warmer with their fur, and in the least, ride them for hours… That´s why some scientist (and I) agree to look for alien signs of intelligence, but being as silent as possible! The difference between SETI and METI.

    I´d rather stay being a kind altruist element of the upper species, asking for the conscience of my fellows. Just in case…

  2. wideawakeinwonderland

    I’ve avoided responding to this because it makes me feel dumb.
    So question: I understand that in THEORY it’s better to be altruistic, but obviously you can look around you and see that pretty much no one here on earth cares about that.
    Thus, people get trampled to death at the Black Friday Christmas sale at Wal-Mart.
    So I’m sticking to my guns: Humans are jerks.